For the past 3 years I have actively engaged in supporting selected entrepreneurs through the charity website Lendwithcare with micro-financing. Actually this morning, I received notification that my latest entrepreneur, a peanut farmer in Ecuador was now fully funded – fabulous news. Lendwithcare is an initiative of CARE International UK, and one such micro-financing platform available via internet searches. Their target client-base are primarily small businesses run by entrepreneurs who are introduced generally through in-country micro-finance institutions in their local region to available low-cost finance opportunities, which would be in most cases unavailable to them. The Lendwithcare website delivery is easy to follow, and to use, to identify entrepreneurs in need of assistance. Thereafter, the Lendwithcare team provide regular updates and monthly account information. Indeed, to me, I consider that this platform does not increase hardship on those who take loans to underpin business growth , expansion or temporary support – the majority of the loans taken are of a relatively low in amount in greater business terms.
“Lendwithcare is a revolutionary way to help people in low income countries to work their way out of poverty with dignity. Lendwithcare allows you to lend as little as £15 to fund a small business and once your money is repaid you can choose to recycle your loan to support another entrepreneur, or withdraw your money.” From the Lendwithcare website.
My interest in micro-financing was significantly driven by my daughter who had spent time in Honduras working for Project Trust, an international volunteering charity for young people based on the Isle of Coll in Scotland, at a linked sponsored school. During her time on the ground in Honduras she got to know about micro-financing through a friend who worked for another charitable organisation. She brought this idea/programme to my attention. Thereafter, I conducted further research on the internet. This is when I came across Lendwithcare, and became interested in their mission – http://www.lendwithcare.org -. I therefore registered with them and started funding with an initial £15 loan payment. As I said previously, their website provides an overview of individual entrepreneurs/business owners, or groups, in their own country with photos and background stories, their vision, and how much they would like to loan, along with how the money will be spent. Then collectively the offered individual loans are added to the total until the amount requested is 100% fulfilled – you can see how much is left to fund on each promoted application. Then an email will sent to say that all has been funded. Thereafter, each month repayments are made to your account until the all monthly payments have been met.
Of note, during the pandemic Covid-19 period Lendwithcare have acted responsibly and not taken loan repayments allowing the entrepreneurs to take a funding holiday.
That said, I have also read a viewpoint that micro-financing actually is not a good programme for helping those in poorer countries and does not help to alleviate poverty. This may have been specifically targeted more at individuals, rather small businesses. Much of course in my view will be the T&Cs of the loans taken , and by whom they are offered. For instance some listed micro-finance operations will want a percentage return on its investment, which might not be the case with all charity offerings.
Further whist reviewing I came across the following excerpt:
“When micro-loans are used to fund new businesses, budding entrepreneurs tend to encounter a lack of consumer demand. After all, their potential customers are poor and low on cash, and what little money they do have gets spent on basic goods that tend already to be available. In this context, new businesses end up displacing already-existing ones, yielding no net increase in employment and incomes. And that’s the best of the likely outcomes. The worst – and much more likely – is that the new businesses fail, which then leads, once again, to vicious cycles of over-indebtedness that drive borrowers even further into poverty.” Jason Hickel, The micro-finance delusion: who really wins?, The Guardian 2015
So the on-going question is whether micro-financing is good or bad idea, and this will depend much on your own viewpoint. The answer I am sure sits firmly with the entrepreneurs who receive this funding they would otherwise be unable to source. In my my mind any negative stance is outweighed my own experience so far. I personally feel that together my fellow Lendwithcare funders that we are helping entrepreneurs and business owners, and not facilitating further hardship and misery.